LRTs

(EN)    (FR)    (DE)

(EN)

1.       A History of LRT in the system

The EURSC is an International Organisation managed by the OSG. The OSG reports to the Board of Governors[1]. (See European School - Wikipedia. The European schools do not fall under the EU or jurisdiction of member states.

“Article 3 of the 1994 Convention Defining the Statute of the European Schools[2] declares that classroom education in the European Schools is guaranteed by (European) Member States appointing their own national teachers to each European School. Unfortunately, this idealistic system does not work fully in practice”[2]

The LRT have been part of the system from the beginning filling in the gaps because fully staffing by Secondment is not feasible. (The member states contribute financially through the salaries of the seconded teachers, The Commission effectively covers the rest of the teaching costs (Including the local part of the Seconded costs and the LRT). As with all school systems the only real resource they have and therefore only real cost are the teachers salaries.

As the system grew the need for LRT grew and the requirements of the LRT became more professional. This was increased in 2013 when the UK decided to reduce it’s staff contribution to be proportional to the number of UK students

The article The Plea of the Locally Recruited Teachers – A Study on the Failure of Cost-Sharing within the European Schools is a must read.
Since 2013-14 the Board of Governors has continued to try to get a 65-35%[3] balance between the Seconded teaching staff and the Locally recruited teaching staff. The OSG uses a “Per hour” model to calculate this and because all Secondments are full-time posts the actual number of locally recruited teachers is greater than the percentage split. There have been numerous efforts, still ongoing, to make Secondment more attractive yet the model still is not working!

The main political drive behind the re-balancing of the contributions comes of course from the Commission who are paying the difference. As they are a major stakeholder their decisions cut across all the financial decisions of the system.
The European Schools sit in the budget of DG Human Resources – the schools being an essential resource facilitating the mobility of key workers.



[2] The Plea of the Locally Recruited Teachers – A Study on the Failure of Cost-Sharing within the European Schools (13stars.eu)

[3] Sharing of the costs of seconded staff amongst the Member States (Cost sharing) 2018-10-D-62-en-4



1.    The Statute[1] - Employment conditions to be developed

The statute is effectively your service contract – who’s read it?
Getting as far as Article 3 should set alarm bells ringing!
You will have been given a copy when you signed your first contract with your school.

The statute has been developed through consultation – working groups with busy teachers trying to share the concerns and promote the needs of all busy teachers. Those involved did an incredible job with the limited resources we made available to them but, in hindsight we should have been better organised. Before the statute our official, renumerated and empowered, representation was a Seconded teacher who we could not vote for (see a problem?). We placed a great deal of faith in Office Secretary General to create a good statute. What was produced was, and has always been said to have been, a starting point.

The need for one statute to cover all the schools was;

·         A drive for professionalism and equality
As the numbers of secondments were allowed to fall the role fulfilled by the LRT changed, most notably in secondary where previously the BAC cycle was almost entirely the preserve of the seconded teachers and LRT filled in the gaps in the younger classes. The system has become reliant on LRT and had to ensure quality.

·         Contracts under national law were becoming a distraction for OSG.
Legal challenges across many countries were expensive especially as one successful challenge would lead to other countries asking for the same. As each country tried to fit our statute under its own employment practices.
From a management point of view one set of rules covering the majority of employment conditions is very appealing. As is having an internal independent appeals body. The gateway to the appeals body is the OSG and it is an expensive system as local employment layers have to learn how this system works.

·         Representation
Prior to 2011 the LRT could not vote for the teacher representative. Representatives were seconded teachers elected by seconded teachers.
(We have done a lot of learning since then!)

·         Mobility
Mobility across the system for LRT (Is that really necessary?)

 

A complete statute change required 100% agreement at BoG[2] level so we got a compromise that could subsequently be amended with 70% approval. LRT teachers were consulted while being told that this is the best you can have, for now. We started out with a compromised statute.

A teaching qualification became a requirement with the 2011 Statute forcing a number of colleagues with long term experience in the system out.

We now have the 2016 statute which highlights how the pay scales have diminished over time.
(Current starting gross is 83% of pre 2011 starting gross and after 20years of service reaching the top step which is 97% of pre-2011 starting gross)

All LRT in theory work under the same rules but these are applied differently by different managers. The OSG will oversee and step in to correct but only if something is challenged. What are not published are the memoranda from OSG clarifying to management how the statutes should be applied. These should be referenced and easily available to at the very least our elected representatives (Few people know they exist).

 

The latest amendments (February 2022) show that improvements are possible.
We are now, for example, allowed access to the same health system as the seconded teachers. I would describe this as “Crumbs from the table.”
This health system should not have been open to all teachers from the start but for whatever reason LRT were excluded. It is a minor cost if not cost neutral.

We were promised “Green travel” incentives when the PAS won the right to them in their statute (In-line with Belgian employment practices).
This, we were told would be simple as there is a precedent. NOW we are told it doesn’t fit with what the commission wants to do with it’s flexible working so we have to fight and demand – tiring and demotivating.

(FR)

(DE)